Table of Contents
Richard Florida's Rise of the Creative Class makes a compelling argument that urban development now depends on novel combinations of knowledge and ideas, that certain occupations specialize in this task, that people in these occupations are drawn to areas providing a high quality of life, and that the essential development strategy is to create an environment that attracts and retains these workers. While developed with urban areas in mind, this thesis may be particularly relevant in rural areas, which lose much of their young talent as high school graduates leave for college, the armed forces, or "city lights."
Our analysis of recent development in rural U.S. counties, which focuses on natural amenities (for which ERS has also computed county-level scores) as quality-of-life indicators, supports the creative class thesis (see Recasting the Creative Class to Examine Growth Processes in Rural and Urban Counties PDF icon (16x16) and The Creative Class: A Key to Rural Growth). A repetition for urban counties also shows a strong relationship between creative class presence and growth, although creative class employment plays a smaller role. However, our results depend on a recast creative class measure, which excludes from the original Florida measure many occupations with low creativity requirements and those involved primarily in services to the residential community (i.e., with numbers roughly proportional to population). Our measure conforms more closely to the concept of creative class and proves to be more highly associated with regional development than the original Florida measure.
Other work by Florida has demonstrated that a critical subset of the creative class is that comprised of fine, performing, and applied artists. His "Bohemian index"—the share of employment in arts occupations—is strongly associated with new firm formation and high-tech specialization in metropolitan areas. ERS research (see Emoting with their feet: Bohemian attraction to creative milieu 16x16 - PDF , Journal of Economic Geography, August 2007) confirms that nonmetro counties with a surplus of artists tend to have higher rates of employment growth and new firm formation. The creative class codes data file also breaks out the share of employment in the arts.
Identifying Creative Occupations Using 2000 Census Data
O*NET, a Bureau of Labor Statistics data set that describes the skills generally used in occupations, was used to identify occupations that involve a high level of "thinking creatively." This skill element is defined as "developing, designing, or creating new applications, ideas, relationships, systems, or products, including artistic contributions." See examples of occupation's O*NET skill ranking for the "thinking creatively" descriptor.
The O*NET compendium, previously known as the Dictionary of Occupational Titles, is produced by the Employment and Training Administration, U.S. Department of Labor, and provides comprehensive information on the functional requirements of more than 1,000 detailed occupations. The creativity measure provides a quantitative, though arguably imperfect, reference for assessing the creativity requirements among summary occupations that typically require a high degree of education.
Refining the Occupation Classification
Occupations were removed from consideration in the creative class measure—even if they typically required high levels of creativity—when their numbers are generally proportional to the residential population they serve (such as schoolteachers, judges, and medical doctors). Specifically, the measure excludes the summary "health care practitioners and technical occupations" group and schoolteachers and aides in the "education, training, and library" occupational group. We argue that such economic reproduction character does not disqualify college professors and "librarians, curators, and archivists" as their services are often provided to a nonresident population. Purging legal support occupations and judges while retaining lawyers might be questioned. However, the important role that lawyers play in devising solutions to new problems created by economic development is a compelling argument for their inclusion.
"Life, physical, and social science technicians" are excluded from the recast classification due to generally low requirements for creative thinking, although technicians in "architecture and engineering occupations" are retained due to higher requirements for creative thinking. This same justification for exclusion applies to "business operations specialists" and "other financial specialists" within the "business and financial operations" occupational group. Within "management occupations," "farmers and farm managers" are excluded due to low creativity requirements of farmers as reported in O*NET. However, management positions in public administration that would be appropriately excluded given the economic reproduction criterion are not separated from other management positions in the classification and so are retained. "Supervisory sales" creates a problem as many small business owners fall in this category, yet in the 2000 Census of Population, the category is mixed with other sales occupations (although not retail sales and cashiers). We have kept this larger category in the recast creative class as we are uncomfortable with excluding small business owners.
Creative class as reformulated by ERS
Occupation title Standard Occupation Code (SOC)
Top executives 11-1000
Advertising, marketing, promotions, public relations, and sales managers 11-2000
Financial managers 11-3030
Operations specialties managers, except financial managers 11-3010, 11-3020, 11-3040 through 11-3070
Other management occupations, except farmers and farm managers 11-9020 through 11-9190
Business and financial operations occupations:
Accountants and auditors 13-2011
Computer and mathematical occupations:
Computer specialists 15-1000
Mathematical science occupations 15-2000
Architecture and engineering occupations:
Architects, surveyors, and cartographers 17-1000
Drafters, engineering, and mapping technicians 17-3000
Life, physical, and social science occupations:
Life and physical scientists 19-1000 and 19-2000
Social scientists and related workers 19-3000
Education, training, and library occupations:
Postsecondary teachers 25-1000
Librarians, curators, and archivists 25-4000
Arts, design, entertainment, sports, and media occupations:
Art and design workers* 27-1000*
Entertainers and performers, sports, and related workers* 27-2000*
Media and communications workers 27-3000 and 27-4000
Sales and related occupations:
Sales representatives, services, wholesale and manufacturing 41-3000 and 41-4000
Other sales and related occupations, including supervisors 41-1000 and 41-9000
*These two categories comprise the arts occupation subset.
Using the occupations as detailed in the table, data from the 2000 Census of Population, summary file 4 was compiled for 3,139 counties (due to small sample size there are no data for Kalawao, HI, and Loving, TX). The share of the employed population 16 years and older in these occupations represents the ERS measure of creative class.
The creative class measure was also constructed for 1990. Creative class occupations from the finest level of detail in the 2000 Census occupational data (93 occupations) were used to define the 1990 creative class, constructed from 1990 Equal Employment Opportunity special tabulation files, much more disaggregate data (512 occupations). A major change in the Standard Occupational Classification codes between 1990 and 2000 complicated the construction of comparable measures, as the 2000 occupations did not correspond to summary 1990 occupations. The majority of the codes in 2000 could be constructed from the disaggregate 1990 data, but a number of detailed 1990 occupations were distributed across creative class and non-creative class occupational codes in 2000. Conversion factors that partitioned the 1990 data to correspond with the 2000 codes were computed from the U.S. Census Bureau's Technical Paper #65 ( The Relationship Between The 1990 Census and Census 2000 Industry and Occupation Classification Systems ) for "managers and administrators, n.e.c., salaried;" "inspectors and compliance officers, except construction;" and "sales representatives, mining, manufacturing, and wholesale."
The change in the Standard Occupational Classification also affected the compilation of arts occupations as a subset of the creative class. Within the 93 detailed occupations included in the 2000 Census STF4 file, "Art and design workers" and "Entertainers and performers, sports, and related workers" are the only two categories that are not substantially co-mingled with non-arts occupations. The corresponding 1990 occupational categories are "Designers," "Painters, sculptors, craft-artists, and artist printmakers," "Photographers," and "Artists, performers, and related workers, n.e.c.," "Musicians and composers," "Actors and directors," "Dancers" and "Athletes." The 2000 aggregation does not allow purging athletes from the data series, though they comprise a minimal share of the total, nor does it allow the inclusion of authors who are co-mingled with the considerably larger number of technical writers.
These refinements resulted in an estimated creative class share of the workforce of 21 percent in 1990 (23 percent in metro areas and 14 percent in nonmetro areas) and 25 percent in 2000 (27 percent in metro and 17 percent in nonmetro).
Updating the Creative Class Codes with 2007-11 American Community Survey Data
Updating the 2000 Census creative class data with 2010 Census creative class data is not possible because the long form sent to 1 in 6 households to collect detailed data such as occupation is no longer used. Instead, the American Community Survey (ACS)—a continuous survey that samples 1 in 40 households each year—now provides the detailed data that had been collected through the long form. While this major change in data collection strategy greatly increases the timeliness of these detailed data for the nation, States, and large cities, generating reliable estimates for smaller settlements and nonmetropolitan counties requires pooling 5 years of ACS data. By pooling 5 years of data, taking into account nonresponse, we can achieve an effective sampling rate of about 1 in 11 households. Thus, the latest update provided is for pooled data collected for 2007 through 2011.
The change from the decennial Census summary file 4 to the 5-year pooled ACS file also affected the level of detail of occupational categories that are published and made available to the public. The 93 occupations in the 2000 summary file 4 have been collapsed into 26 occupations in the publicly available ACS file which is too coarse an aggregation to construct a creative class measure that is comparable. ERS ordered a special tabulation from the Census Bureau that uses unpublished disaggregated occupational categories to replicate the 2000 creative class measure. The specification by detailed occupational category from the latest 2010 Standard Occupation Classification used in the 2007-11 ACS ( SOC Code to Census Code Crosswalk Excel icon (16x16) ) is available on the Census website, and also provided below:
Occupation 2010 Description 2010 Census Code
Total Creative Occupations Sum of all rows
Total Artistic Occupations Sum of artistic subgroups
Chief executives and legislators 0010, 0030
General and operations managers 0020
Advertising and promotions managers 0040
Marketing and sales managers 0050
Public relations and fundraising managers 0060
Administrative services managers 0100
Computer and information systems managers 0110
Financial managers 0120
Compensation and benefits managers 0135
Human resources managers 0136
Training and development managers 0137
Industrial production managers 0140
Purchasing managers 0150
Transportation, storage, and distribution managers 0160
Construction managers 0220
Education administrators 0230
Architectural and engineering managers 0300
Food service managers 0310
Gaming managers 0330
Lodging managers 0340
Medical and health services managers 0350
Natural sciences managers 0360
Property, real estate, and community association managers 0410
Social and community service managers 0420
Emergency management directors 0425
Miscellanous managers, including funeral service managers and postmasters and mail superintendents 0325, 0400, 0430
Accountants and auditors 0800
Computer and information research scientists 1005
Computer systems analysts 1006
Information security analysts 1007
Computer programmers 1010
Software developers, applications and systems software 1020
Web developers 1030
Computer support specialists 1050
Database administrators 1060
Network and computer systems administrators 1105
Computer network architects 1106
Computer occupations, all other 1107
Operations research analysts 1220
Miscellaneous mathematical science occupations, including mathematicians and statisticians 1210, 1230, 1240
Architects, except naval 1300
Surveyors, cartographers, and photogrammetrists 1310
Aerospace engineers 1320
Biomedical engineers and agricultural engineers 1330, 1340
Chemical engineers 1350
Civil engineers 1360
Computer hardware engineers 1400
Electrical and electronics engineers 1410
Environmental engineers 1420
Industrial engineers, including health and safety 1430
Marine engineers and naval architects 1440
Materials engineers 1450
Mechanical engineers 1460
Petroleum, mining, and geological engineers, including mine safety engineers 1500, 1520
Miscellaneous engineers, including nuclear engineers 1510, 1530
Engineering technicians, except drafters 1550
Surveying and mapping technicians 1560
Agricultural and food scientists 1600
Biological scientists 1610
Conservation scientists and foresters 1640
Medical scientists and life scientists, all others 1650, 1660
Astronomers and physicists 1700
Atmospheric and space scientists 1710
Chemists and materials scientists 1720
Environmental scientists and geoscientists 1740
Physical scientists, all other 1760
Urban and regional planners 1840
Miscellaneous social scientists, including survey researchers and sociologists 1815, 1830, 1860
Postsecondary teachers 2200
Archivists, curators, and museum technicians 2400
Library technicians 2440
Artists and related workers 2600 - Artistic Subgroup
Designers 2630 - Artistic Subgroup
Actors 2700 - Artistic Subgroup
Producers and directors 2710 - Artistic Subgroup
Athletes, coaches, umpires, and related workers 2720 - Artistic Subgroup
Dancers and choreographers 2740 - Artistic Subgroup
Musicians, singers, and related workers 2750 - Artistic Subgroup
Entertainers and performers, sports and related workers, all other 2760 - Artistic Subgroup
News analysts, reporters and correspondents 2810
Public relations specialists 2825
Technical writers 2840
Writers and authors 2850
Miscellaneous media and communication workers 2860
Broadcast and sound engineering technicians and radio operators and media and communication equipment workers, all other 2900, 2960
Television, video, and motion picture camera operators and editors 2920
First-line supervisors of retail sales workers 4700
First-line supervisors of non-retail sales workers 4710
Advertising sales agents 4800
Insurance sales agents 4810
Securities, commodities, and financial services sales agents 4820
Travel agents 4830
Sales representatives, services, all other 4840
Sales representatives, wholesale and manufacturing 4850
Models, demonstrators, and product promoters 4900
Real estate brokers and sales agents 4920
Sales engineers 4930
Door-to-door sales workers, news and street vendors, and related workers 4950
Sales and related workers, all other 4965
The major benefit accompanying the special tabulation is the provision of standard errors accompanying each creative occupation and arts occupation estimate. The standard errors provide information on the reliability of the estimate. Since the estimate is derived from a sample of the population, it might vary substantially if the size of the total sample is relatively small and if the phenomenon of interest is relative rare. For example, suppose the true share of artists is 0.01 or 1 in 100 employees in a county. If a county has 1100 total employees, then the estimate will be based on about 100 respondents. By the luck of the draw, the sample chosen for the county could contain no artists, 1 or more artists, or (improbably) all 11 artists. The standard error provides an exact statistical measure of the reliability of the estimate. This is very valuable in comparing creative or arts occupation shares between 2007-11 and 2000, as a nominal increase or decrease in share may be due solely to sampling error. Formulas for comparing estimates across time periods incorporating standard error are provided in Appendix 4 of A Compass for Understanding and Using American Community Survey Data: What Researchers Need to Know PDF icon (16x16) .
For a complete discussion of ERS research on the creative class, see Recasting the Creative Class To Examine Growth Processes in Rural and Urban Counties 16x16 - PDF , by David A. McGranahan and Timothy R. Wojan, Regional Studies Vol. 41 No. 2, pp. 197-216, April 2007.
Recasting the Creative Class To Examine Growth Processes in Rural and Urban Counties 16x16 - PDF , by David A. McGranahan and Timothy R. Wojan, Regional Studies Vol. 41 No. 2, pp. 197-216, April 2007.
Arts Employment Is Burgeoning in Some Rural Areas and The Creative Class: A Key to Rural Growth, in Amber Waves magazine.
Emoting with Their Feet: Bohemian Attraction to Creative Milieu 16x16 - PDF , by Timothy R. Wojan, D.M. Lambert, and D.A. McGranahan, Journal of Economic Geography 2007; Digital Object Identifier (DOI): 10.1093/jeg/lbm029.
The Rural Growth Trifecta: Outdoor Amenities, Creative Class and Entrepreneurial Context 16x16 - PDF , by David A. McGranahan, Timothy R. Wojan and Dayton M. Lambert Journal of Economic Geography, May 2011. Digital Object Identifier (DOI): 093/jeg/lbq007.